Comparison · Updated November 21, 2026

Shopify Payments is Shopify’s own branded payments service — processed by Stripe, per Shopify’s published processor list — giving merchants one-click access to accepting cards and wallets inside Shopify, simplifying setup and eliminating third-party gateway fees for supported merchants.

Squarespace Payments is the native payment processor inside Squarespace, the New York website builder founded by Anthony Casalena in 2003 and taken private by Permira in October 2024 for about $7.2bn. Announced in October 2023 and rolled out first in the United States, it now covers fifteen countries and lets a Squarespace merchant accept cards, ACH, Klarna, Afterpay and other methods without connecting Stripe or PayPal, with payments, payouts, refunds and disputes managed inside the Squarespace dashboard. Underneath, Squarespace's own help documentation describes Stripe as its processing services partner, so this is a payment facilitator layered on Stripe rather than a new acquirer. US pricing is published in full: 2.9% plus 30¢ on standard cards on the Basic and Core plans, 2.7% on Plus and 2.5% on Advanced, a 1.5% surcharge on international cards, 3.2% plus 30¢ on American Express and premium cards, ACH at 1% to 1.5%, and a $20 dispute fee. Payouts are daily and reach a US bank account in one to two business days. The case for it is convenience and, on the higher plans, a modest rate cut; the case against is that it is no cheaper than Stripe direct on the plans most merchants are on, it is locked to Squarespace, and a steady stream of complaints describes risk holds on funds with no phone number to call.
We compare the two for a small US online store paid in dollars to a US bank account, on the entry plans each publishes in the US: Shopify Basic against Squarespace's cheapest selling plan, Basic, and the same-priced Core plan. Prices and rates were read on Shopify's and Squarespace's own US pricing pages and help centres on 21 November 2026. Both are built-in processors that only work inside their own platform, and Stripe sits behind both in the US: Shopify's published processor list names Stripe, Inc. and PayPal, Inc. as the US payment processors for Shopify Payments, and Squarespace's dispute guide calls Stripe its processing services partner. On a standard card both charge 2.9% + $0.30. The difference is the platform fee around it. Shopify adds nothing on Shopify Payments sales but charges 2% on Basic if you use another processor. Squarespace adds 2% to online sales on its $19 Basic plan, whichever processor you use, and its $29 Core plan, priced like Shopify Basic, removes that fee on physical goods. On a like-priced plan, Shopify Payments is cheaper on international cards, on chargebacks ($15 against $20) and in person (2.6% + $0.10 against the 2.9% + $0.30 card rate that Squarespace applies to Tap to Pay). Squarespace is cheaper on American Express and other premium cards (3.2% against 3.5% + $0.30), offers ACH from 1%, and reaches 2.7% and 2.5% card rates on cheaper plans than Shopify does. Neither has a processing contract or a cancellation fee.
Shopify Payments is for a store built on Shopify that sells physical or digital goods online and also in person: 2.9% + $0.30 online and 2.6% + $0.10 in person on the $29 Basic plan, no platform fee on its own sales, a $15 chargeback fee, Shop Pay at checkout and 24/7 live chat. Accept that premium cards cost 3.5% + $0.30, that a standard payout takes three to five business days, and that switching to another processor on Basic adds a 2% fee.
Squarespace Payments is for a Squarespace site on Core or above that sells mostly online, sees a fair share of American Express, or collects large invoices by ACH: 2.9% + $0.30 on Core, 3.2% + $0.30 on premium cards, ACH at 1% for payments of $250 or more, and lower card rates on the $49 Plus and $99 Advanced plans. Avoid running a real store on Basic, where 2% of every online sale goes to Squarespace, and note the $20 chargeback fee, the lack of phone support and the thin in-person option.
It depends on which platform you are on and how you sell. On a standard US card both charge 2.9% + $0.30 on their entry plans, and Shopify Basic and Squarespace Core cost the same $29 a month billed yearly, so for a plain online store of physical goods the cost is level. Shopify Payments is the better buy for a store that also sells in person (2.6% + $0.10 against 2.9% + $0.30 on Squarespace's Tap to Pay, and chip and swipe readers on its own processing), sells digital products, takes many foreign cards or wants the lower $15 chargeback fee and live chat that Shopify states runs 24/7. Squarespace Payments is the better buy for a Squarespace site on Core or above that sees a lot of American Express (3.2% against 3.5% + $0.30), collects large payments by ACH, or wants 2.7% or 2.5% card rates without paying for Shopify's $79 or $299 plans. Squarespace's $19 Basic plan is the expensive way in: its 2% transaction fee outweighs the $10 yearly-billed saving once online physical-goods sales pass about $500 a month.
| Feature | Shopify Payments | Squarespace Payments |
|---|---|---|
| Cheapest plan that can sell | Basic: $29/mo yearly, $39 monthly | Basic: $19/mo yearly, $25 monthly |
| As of 21 November 2026, from each company's US pricing page. Squarespace's Basic plan carries a 2% online-store transaction fee (next row). Its Core plan costs $29 a month billed yearly or $39 monthly, exactly the price of Shopify Basic, and has no transaction fee on physical goods. Shopify's pricing page also advertises 'Earn 1% back on all sales as subscription credits' (up to $5,000 on Basic); its promotion terms (updated 2 December 2025) limit this to invited merchants for six months, and the credits only pay future Shopify subscription fees. Shopify's pricing page shows a trial of 3 days free then $1 a month for 3 months; Squarespace offers a 14-day free trial. | ||
| Platform fee on online physical-goods sales | None with Shopify Payments Winner | 2% on Basic; 0% on Core and above |
| Squarespace's fees article (updated November 2026) applies the commerce transaction fee to sales of physical products, downloads and services and to donations, and refunds it when you refund a Squarespace Payments order; its processor guide says the fee is set by the billing plan and what you sell, so it applies whichever processor you use. Its pricing page says invoices carry no transaction fee. On a $50 sale with a standard card, Shopify Basic costs $1.75 and Squarespace Basic $2.75 ($1.75 processing plus $1.00 transaction fee). At $5,000 a month of online sales in 100 orders, Shopify Basic and Squarespace Core each cost $204 a month including the yearly-billed plan; Squarespace Basic costs $294. Squarespace Basic's $10 yearly-billed saving over Core is used up at $500 a month of such sales (2% of $500); on monthly billing ($25 against $39) the crossover is $700. | ||
| Platform fee on digital products | None with Shopify Payments Winner | 7% Basic, 5% Core, 1% Plus, 0% Advanced |
| Squarespace's 'Digital Content and Memberships' transaction fee applies to courses, memberships and other digital products, on top of processing. Shopify's pricing page lists no platform fee on Shopify Payments sales of any kind. | ||
| Fee for using another processor | 2% on Basic (1% Grow, 0.6% Advanced) | None beyond the plan's own transaction fee Winner |
| Shopify charges a third-party transaction fee on top of the outside processor's own fees whenever you take payments through a provider other than Shopify Payments (0.2% on Plus). Squarespace's transaction fee is set by the plan and what you sell, not by the processor, so connecting Stripe or PayPal instead of Squarespace Payments costs nothing extra beyond that processor's own rates. Squarespace Payments can only be connected alongside PayPal, not alongside Stripe or Square. | ||
| Commitment | Monthly or yearly plan; cancel anytime | Monthly or annual plan; cancel anytime |
| Neither has a separate processing contract or an early-termination fee. Shopify's pricing FAQ: 'simply cancel your account' (only 1- or 3-year Plus terms run to term). Squarespace's pricing FAQ: changes and cancellations take effect at the end of the current billing cycle, with service continuing through the paid period; if a site is cancelled, Squarespace Payments is disabled but payouts still proceed. | ||
Recommendations based on your business type

Shopify Basic charges 2.6% + $0.10 in person and works with a card reader as well as Tap to Pay. Squarespace Payments takes in-person cards only by Tap to Pay on a phone, at the plan's card rate of 2.9% + $0.30 on Basic and Core; a Square Reader in the Squarespace app is processed by Square.

Shopify adds no platform fee to Shopify Payments sales. Squarespace adds a digital-products transaction fee of 7% on Basic, 5% on Core and 1% on Plus; only its $99 Advanced plan removes it.

On Core the card rate is the same 2.9% + $0.30 as Shopify Basic at the same $29 plan price, American Express costs 3.2% + $0.30 against Shopify's 3.5%, and there is no transaction fee on physical goods. Moving to Plus ($49 a month billed yearly) cuts standard cards to 2.7% + $0.30.

Squarespace Payments takes ACH at 1% on Core and above (1.5% on Basic, capped at $10 on Advanced) for payments of $250 or more. Shopify Payments' ACH direct debit is for B2B orders only, with no published rate.
Both. Squarespace Basic is the cheapest selling plan at $19 a month billed yearly, but its 2% transaction fee makes Core cheaper above about $500 a month in online physical-goods sales on yearly billing (about $700 on monthly billing). Shopify Basic costs $29 a month billed yearly with no platform fee. At small volumes either works; choose the website builder you prefer, since each processor only works on its own platform.
Common questions about this comparison
Explore more payment processor matchups