Payment Processing · Buyer guide

Direct Debit is still the default way to collect a recurring payment in the UK. A gym, a club, a subscription or a business invoicing the same clients monthly can pull the money from the customer's bank account on a date it chooses, with no card to expire. What it costs depends on who you collect through, and few providers publish a price.
Here is what Bacs Direct Debit costs at the providers that print a UK price, read from their own pages in November 2026, how it compares with card and pay by bank, and the rules that decide how safe the money is once it lands.
Bacs, run by Pay.UK, describes a three-day cycle: the collection file goes in on day one, between 07:00 and 22:30; it reaches the payers' banks on day two; and on day three their accounts are debited and yours credited. Before that you need a Direct Debit Instruction, or mandate, from each customer.
Providers add their own steps on top of that cycle. Stripe's documentation says a Bacs payment takes 4 business days to confirm when a mandate is already in place and up to 7 when a new mandate is being set up, with funds typically available in your Stripe balance at T+4 after submission on an existing mandate, or T+7 when a new mandate is being collected. Mollie says Bacs payments typically take up to three business days to clear, and lists a settlement delay of 5 business days.
Customers must also be told before they are charged. The Bacs FAQ says the default advance-notice period, unless you have agreed another one with the customer, is at least 10 working days plus postal time, and the Direct Debit Guarantee repeats that customers will be notified of any change in amount, date or frequency, normally 10 working days ahead "or as otherwise agreed". Providers set their own shorter agreed period in the mandate: Stripe's mandate requirements specify a 2-working-day advance notice period.
As of November 2026, from each provider's UK pricing page. GoCardless states its prices exclude VAT; Stripe, Mollie and Adyen do not say on their price lists whether VAT applies, so their figures are shown exactly as printed.
Specialist Direct Debit bureaux also sell to small businesses; they are not reviewed on this site, so they are not compared here.
On a £40 monthly membership, the published prices come to the following, as printed (only GoCardless says its prices exclude VAT):
On a £1,500 business invoice the picture flips. GoCardless Standard and Stripe both hit their £4 cap (£4.80 at GoCardless once its VAT is added). Adyen stays at 66p. Mollie, with no cap on its price list, comes to £13.70. For a business with large, infrequent payments, the cap matters far more than the percentage.
Cards are dearer per payment on the same provider's price list. Stripe charges 1.5% + 20p on a standard UK card and 2.8% + 20p on a premium UK card, so the £40 membership costs 80p by standard card against 40p by Bacs. Mollie charges 1.20% + £0.20 on a UK consumer card, 68p on the same £40, and 2.90% + £0.20 on UK commercial cards, which on the £1,500 invoice is £43.70 against £13.70 by Bacs. In-person card rates are a separate market; our guide to UK card machine fees covers them.
One-off pay by bank, where the customer approves a payment in their banking app and it moves over Faster Payments, is now priced close to Direct Debit. Stripe lists Pay by Bank at 0.5% + 20p capped at £5, and Mollie at 0.45% + £0.20. GoCardless includes it in the same plan fee as Direct Debit and says the 0.3% high-value surcharge does not apply to it. TrueLayer, one of the larger open banking providers, publishes no merchant price list. Our guide to pay by bank for merchants covers the one-off version in more detail.
A variable recurring payment lets a customer give a provider standing permission to take payments from their account within limits they set. Commercial VRPs, paying a business rather than moving money between a person's own accounts, went live under a new industry scheme run by UK Payments Initiative Ltd (UKPI), which launched on 2 June 2026; the FCA published a statement welcoming it the same day.
UKPI has started with a limited set of uses. Its launch posts name payments to charities, government, utilities and financial services as Wave 1, and a September update adds rail journeys. Subscriptions, wider e-commerce and retail are described as the next step, with purchase protection, dispute resolution and pricing for them still being defined. A gym, a members' club or a software subscription is not in the first wave. UKPI's published rulebook provides for a per-payment fee the payment initiation provider pays the customer's bank, but the pricing schedule that sets it is not included in the published rulebook, and we found no regulator-set cap on what a merchant pays.
GoCardless markets a Recurring Pay by Bank product with no separate published price. Stripe's Pay by Bank Recurring, in private preview, takes the first payment by bank and sets up a Bacs mandate for the rest, so the recurring part is still Direct Debit.
Under the Direct Debit Guarantee, which every bank and building society offering Direct Debit gives its customers, a customer debited in error is entitled to a full and immediate refund from their own bank. The Bacs FAQ explains what happens next: the customer's bank refunds them and then reclaims the money from you through an indemnity claim. If the bank asks for a copy of the Direct Debit Instruction, you have seven working days to provide it, or you must refund.
There is no deadline on that claim. NatWest's Direct Debit factsheet, dated November 2018, says a business it sponsors must give an indemnity "unlimited in time and amount". Stripe's documentation says there is no set time limit for a Bacs dispute, that you cannot submit evidence or appeal, and that the bank's decision is final. GoCardless says the same about time, and offers a chargeback challenge service only on its Pro plan. GoCardless notes that an indemnity claim does not affect your agreement with the customer, so you can still pursue them for payment, but outside the Direct Debit scheme.
That is the single biggest difference from commercial VRP. UKPI's rulebook requires a customer to claim a refund from their bank for an unauthorised or incorrectly executed payment without undue delay and no later than 13 months after the debit date, rather than at any time.
A Direct Debit can still fail for lack of funds, a closed account or a cancelled mandate, and the customer's bank reports it back through a Bacs report called ARUDD. Bacs's own introduction to Direct Debit says an unpaid Direct Debit is taken back from your account two or three working days after it was credited, and that you may re-present it within one month of the date it was first presented, for the same amount. GoCardless says it charges failure and chargeback fees only in the US, Germany and Austria, so a UK merchant pays nothing extra for a failed payment. Stripe's UK price list shows no separate Bacs failure fee, although its retry documentation refers to debit failure fees without giving a Bacs amount; Stripe Billing can retry a payment that failed for insufficient funds up to twice within 30 days. Our guide to ACH return fees shows what US processors charge instead.
Every Direct Debit is collected under a six-digit Service User Number, or SUN. A business can get its own, sponsored by its bank, or it can collect under a provider's SUN. Bacs describes three routes: submitting files directly, submitting through a bank or Bacs-approved bureau, or using a facilities management provider that acts as the service user for businesses without their own SUN. GoCardless and Stripe both collect under their own name by default, which is why your customers see the provider's name on the statement unless you pay for the branding add-on.
Getting your own SUN is a credit decision. Bacs's guide to becoming a user says a sponsoring bank will run a credit check because of the risks and liabilities Direct Debit carries, and NatWest's factsheet says your relationship manager must confirm credit sanction, you must hold a non-personal current account and you must give the unlimited indemnity. NatWest's facilities management option is described as typically used where a business is new and would not meet credit approval in its own right. NatWest's Autopay Online Plus factsheet, dated January 2020 and so possibly out of date, lists a £500 setup fee and £50 a month to submit files through it, VAT-exempt, with transaction charges on top at your existing account tariff. Bacs says that from 1 July 2027 it will no longer be possible to apply for a non-AUDDIS Service User Number, so any new SUN will have to use electronic mandate lodgement.
For a small business, that arithmetic usually points to a provider. A business collecting 300 memberships of £40 a month would pay £120 a month at Stripe's published rate, £168 at Mollie's or £216 at GoCardless Standard including its VAT, with no setup fee. Bank sponsorship would mean software or bureau fees such as NatWest's, the bank's per-item charges and the indemnity on top. Your own SUN makes sense once volumes are large and the business can pass the sponsorship check.
Collecting in Canada too? Pre-authorized debit there runs under Payments Canada's Rule H1, which gives a consumer 90 days to dispute a debit. Our guide to Canadian PAD fees sets out what it costs.


