Payment Processing · Buyer guide

A gym collecting monthly dues, a landlord collecting rent and a consulting firm billing a retainer all want the same thing: to pull the money from the customer's bank account on schedule, without a card fee and without waiting for the customer to remember. In Canada that tool is the pre-authorized debit, or PAD. It is cheap, but it comes with rules that a card does not, and a customer's right to reverse it is longer than most businesses expect.
This guide sets out what PAD costs at the providers that publish a price, read from their own pages on 21 November 2026, what Payments Canada's Rule H1 requires of you, and when an Interac e-Transfer or a card is the better choice.
PADs are governed by Rule H1 of Payments Canada (legally the Canadian Payments Association). The current edition is dated 2026. Your payment provider or bank handles the clearing, but the obligations below fall on you as the payee, and the provider's agreement will pass them to you.
Rule H1 splits PADs into personal and business. A business PAD is one drawn for goods or services related to the payor's own business, such as a supplier billing a retailer. A personal PAD covers the rest, and the rule's list names membership fees, utility bills, insurance premiums and other consumer goods and services. A gym's members and a residential tenant are paying from the personal side.
The difference is the window in which the customer's bank must reimburse a claim:
Within those windows the customer can claim if the debit was not drawn in line with the agreement, if the agreement had been revoked, or if a required confirmation, pre-notification or notice was not given. The customer's bank reimburses on a best-efforts basis immediately, and your provider takes the money back from you. If you think the claim is wrong, the rule says the dispute is settled outside the rules: you have to take it up with the customer yourself.
That is the main difference from a card chargeback. Stripe's documentation says a Canadian PAD dispute is filed on a "no-questions-asked basis", that you cannot submit evidence, and that you cannot win one. A card dispute can at least be contested. As with ACH returns in the US, a bank debit is cheap until it is reversed.
A debit that simply bounces, for insufficient funds, a stop payment or a closed account, is returned separately. Rule H1 allows a dishonoured PAD to be re-presented only for the same amount as the original, so you cannot add your own late or NSF fee to the retry. Any fee you charge the customer has to be collected separately.
As of 21 November 2026, from each provider's own pricing page. Stripe and QuickBooks state their prices in Canadian dollars; GoCardless's figures are from its Canadian page and exclude GST/HST; Helcim, Rotessa and Wave print a dollar sign without naming the currency.
Airwallex documents a Canadian EFT PAD product, but lists it only for businesses registered in the US, UK, EU, Hong Kong, Singapore and Australia, publishes no price, and recommends it only for recurring payments from business payers because of the chargeback risk. Moneris offers Interac's Konek checkout for online sales, whose Interac Direct option pays straight from the customer's bank account and which Moneris says supports recurring payments, but it publishes no price for it.
On a $100 monthly payment, the size of a membership or a small service plan, the published rates work out to $1.40 at Stripe, $1.15 on GoCardless Standard, 75 cents at Helcim, and $1 at QuickBooks and at Wave. At Rotessa the transaction fee is 50 cents, but the $25 monthly fee has to be spread across your payments: with 40 customers, the month costs $45, about $1.13 each.
On a $2,000 invoice the caps decide everything. Stripe stops at CA$5, GoCardless at $3 on Standard or $4 on Advanced, and Helcim at $6. Rotessa still charges 50 cents. QuickBooks and Wave publish no cap, so the same invoice costs $20 at either.
For a card on the same basis, Stripe's own Canadian rate for a domestic card online is 2.9% + CA$0.30: $3.20 on the $100 payment against $1.40 by PAD, and $58.30 on the $2,000 invoice against $5. What you would pay on a card through a traditional merchant account depends on interchange, which changed for small merchants this autumn; see Canada's October 2026 interchange cut. The same cap question decides US invoice costs, covered in what an invoice paid by bank costs.
A failure changes the order. One bounced $100 debit costs $5 at Stripe and Helcim and $30 at Rotessa and QuickBooks, which at Rotessa is 60 times its per-transaction fee. If your customers' accounts often run low, a provider with a low NSF fee can beat one with a lower headline rate. If your customer is a business, its bank may charge it too: RBC's business fee schedule (February 2026) charges $45 for an item returned NSF, including a pre-authorized debit, for each presentment, and National Bank's business fee guide (August 2026) charges the same $45.
Receiving an ordinary Interac e-Transfer is usually free for a business, but the bank schedules differ on the extras:
Interac itself publishes only what banks pay it. For Business Request Money, the requesting business's bank pays Interac 0.35% capped at $3.50, or a flat 35 cents for non-retail customers that meet Interac's qualification criteria, with a one-time $2,000 onboarding fee per such customer. Interac lists it as available through BMO, CIBC, DC Bank, Peoples Trust and Scotiabank. Whether your bank passes any of that on is up to its own fee schedule.
The catch is the direction of the payment. An e-Transfer is sent by the customer, or approved by them each time in the case of a request. Nothing happens if they forget, so it suits invoices and one-off payments better than membership dues or rent collected on the first of the month. It is not a PAD, so Rule H1's reimbursement claims do not apply to it.
Payments Canada's Real-Time Rail went live on 9 November 2026, after a launch date confirmed on 5 November. Its own page says members will be onboarded throughout 2027 and that it is targeting more than nine in ten Canadian bank accounts by the third quarter of 2027. For a small business collecting recurring payments this November, it changes nothing yet: PAD and e-Transfer remain the bank options. The wider picture is in pay by bank in 2026.
For how US gyms weigh the same choice, see what a gym's monthly dues cost to collect.
Collecting from customers in the UK as well? Bacs works differently: there is no time limit on an indemnity claim. Our guide to UK Direct Debit fees covers what it costs and how it works.


