Industry · Payment Processing

For fifteen years, the price of the debit card most Americans carry has been set by a federal rule: no more than 21 cents plus 0.05% of the sale, and a further cent for banks that meet the Federal Reserve's fraud-prevention standards. On 26 October 2026 a federal appeals court agreed that the rule is unlawful. It has not yet stopped applying, and nobody knows what will replace it.
This piece follows our September explainer on the case, which was written while the appeal was pending. Here is what the court decided, when it can take effect, what the card networks' own published rates suggest about an uncapped debit card, and which merchants would actually see the difference.
The case is Corner Post, Inc. v. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, No. 25-3000. Corner Post is a truck stop and convenience store in North Dakota. A unanimous panel of Judges Smith, Benton and Stras heard argument on 13 May 2026 and filed its opinion on 26 October, written by Judge Stras. It affirmed the District of North Dakota's 2025 judgment setting the cap aside, and sent the rule back to the Board to write a new one.
The argument turns on two words in the Durbin Amendment. Congress told the Board to consider the incremental cost a bank incurs in authorizing, clearing and settling a particular debit transaction, and not to consider other costs that are not specific to a particular transaction. The court read incremental cost as marginal cost: what one additional transaction adds to the bank's costs. Fixed costs, which do not vary with the number of transactions, are out. Its example is fraud-detection software bought for a one-time fee, and it added that hardware, software, labor and network connectivity can be just as fixed for some banks.
Two further points in the opinion matter for what comes next. First, the court criticised the single 21-cent figure itself, noting that the statute asks the Board to set standards, plural. Second, it said fees do not have to match marginal cost exactly: the Board may use a proxy, perhaps average variable cost, if it bears a reasonable relationship to banks' marginal costs. What it may not do, in the court's words, is pick a number and hope it is close enough. Without deference to the agency after the Supreme Court's 2024 Loper Bright decision, the court decided the meaning of the statute for itself.
For scale, the Board's own survey found that the average cost of authorization, clearing and settlement on a covered debit transaction was 4.1 cents in 2023. The average interchange fee on those transactions was 23 cents.
Not yet. When the district court vacated the rule in August 2025 it stayed its own order pending appeal, to stop interchange becoming what it called a completely unregulated market. The appeals court's footnote spells out the timing: its decision only becomes effective when it issues its mandate, which happens seven days after the deadline to petition for rehearing, and the parties have 45 days to petition in a case involving a federal agency. Counting from 26 October, the earliest date the cap can fall is 17 December 2026.
Several things could push that back. The Board could ask the full Eighth Circuit to rehear the case, which would hold the mandate until the petition is decided. It could ask for the mandate to be stayed while it petitions the Supreme Court. As of 16 November we found no public statement from the Board on either.
There is also a second case. In Linney's Pizza v. Board of Governors, a federal court in Kentucky reached the opposite conclusion in September 2025 and upheld the rule. That appeal is before the Sixth Circuit, which, according to Latham & Watkins, heard argument on 22 October 2026 and has not yet ruled. If the Sixth Circuit upholds the rule, two appeals courts will disagree about the same regulation, which is the classic route to the Supreme Court.
And the Board still has its own proposal on file. In October 2023 it proposed lowering the cap to 14.4 cents plus 0.04% and a 1.3-cent fraud-prevention adjustment. It has not adopted it, and the court said that pending rulemaking did not affect its review. A new rule built on the court's marginal-cost reading would have to start from different cost data.
There is a ready-made reference point for what large banks' debit cards might cost without a cap, because a large part of the market has never had one. Cards issued by banks and credit unions with less than $10 billion in assets are exempt, and Visa publishes both prices side by side. Its interchange table effective 24 October 2026 lists these consumer debit rates:
The Federal Reserve's network data says the same thing in aggregate. In 2024, covered transactions, 60.7% of all US debit transactions, averaged 23 cents in interchange, or 0.47% of their value. Exempt transactions averaged 51 cents, or 1.21%.
None of this is a forecast. We found no statement from Visa or Mastercard on what they would charge on large banks' cards once the cap is gone, and the Board may move quickly to write a replacement. But it shows the size of the stake: for a typical in-store debit sale the gap is around 30 cents, and online it is about 73 cents. Law firm Squire Patton Boggs wrote this month that without a replacement rule, the market would revert to one in which networks and banks freely negotiated swipe fees.
A change in interchange reaches a merchant only through the pricing model in their contract. If you have never checked which one you are on, our guide to reading a processing statement shows where to look.
On cost-plus pricing, interchange is passed through at whatever the network charges. Helcim publishes interchange plus 0.40% + 8 cents in person for merchants processing up to $50,000 a month, and says that if the bank's cost goes down, yours does too; the same works in reverse. Stax charges a subscription from $99 a month and passes interchange through at 0% markup plus 8 cents in person, and Payment Depot lists the same 0% markup and 8 cents. On any of these, a higher debit interchange rate shows up on the next statement with no notice and nothing to sign.
Flat-rate processors charge one price whatever the card. Square lists 2.6% + 15 cents for a tapped, dipped or swiped payment on its free plan, and Stripe 2.9% + 30 cents for a domestic card online. On a $50 in-store debit sale at Square, the merchant pays $1.45 and roughly 24.5 cents of that is interchange today; the rest is the processor's margin and network fees. If interchange on that card rose to 55 cents, the published rate would not move on its own, but the processor's margin would shrink by about 30 cents.
That is the part flat-rate merchants should watch. Flat rates are priced on the processor's whole card mix, and a debit-heavy mix becomes more expensive to serve. Most merchant agreements let the processor change its fees with notice, and whether you can leave without a termination fee when it does depends on one clause. It is worth finding that clause before any repricing letter arrives, not after.
Two parts of the Durbin Amendment are untouched because they are written into the statute, not chosen by the Board. Every debit card must be enabled on at least two unaffiliated networks, and neither the issuer nor the network may stop a merchant choosing how to route the transaction. And issuers with less than $10 billion in assets remain exempt from the fee limits. Which network a big bank's cards run on can still matter for other reasons, as Capital One's move of its debit cards to the Discover network showed.
Routing is the lever that matters more if the cap goes. Today the cap holds interchange on a covered card close to the same ceiling on every network: the Board's 2023 survey found averages of 24 cents on single-message networks and 22 cents on dual-message ones. If the networks set their own prices on those cards again, the spread between them could widen, and so could the value of routing each transaction to the cheaper one.
It is worth remembering how slowly the last big change in card fees reached merchants: the Visa and Mastercard swipe fee settlement was reported for years before it changed anything on a statement. This one has a date attached, but the date is the earliest the cap can fall, not the day your fees change.


