Payment Processing · Buyer guide

Direct debit is how most Australian gyms, clubs, childcare centres and subscription businesses collect a regular payment. The customer signs a Direct Debit Request once, and the business pulls each payment from their bank account through the Bulk Electronic Clearing System, or BECS, with no card to expire. PayTo, which runs over the New Payments Platform and is approved in the customer's banking app, is the newer alternative.
Here is what both cost at the providers that print an Australian price, read from their own pages in November 2026, what a failed or disputed debit costs, and the rules that decide how long a payment you have collected stays yours.
As of November 2026, from each provider's Australian pricing page. Stripe states that its PayTo and BECS fees include GST; GoCardless states that its prices exclude GST. The worked examples below put both on the same, GST-inclusive basis.
The rest of the field is thinner. Eway publishes card and gateway prices only, and its PayTo page still says the service is not yet available. Fat Zebra and Pin Payments list card pricing only on their pricing pages, and none of Square, Zeller or Adyen publishes an Australian direct debit price that we could find. Specialist direct debit bureaux also sell to Australian businesses; they are not reviewed on this site, so they are not compared here.
On a $50 monthly membership, all figures including GST:
On a $2,000 business invoice every plan hits its cap: A$3.50 at Stripe, $4.40 at GoCardless Standard and $5.50 at Advanced once GST is added. On a $5,000 invoice GoCardless's high-value charge comes in: $4 plus 0.3% of the $2,000 above $3,000 is $10 before GST, or $11 with it, against A$3.50 at Stripe. A new Stripe account would need its default A$10,000 weekly BECS limit raised before invoices that size add up, though.
For a business collecting 300 memberships of $50 a month, that is $240 a month at Stripe and $297 at GoCardless Standard, both including GST.
Cards cost more per payment on the same price list. Stripe charges 1.65% + A$0.30 on a domestic card, including GST (it says lower card pricing starts on 1 April 2027), so the $50 membership costs about $1.13 by card against 80c by direct debit, and the $2,000 invoice costs $33.30 against A$3.50. Since 1 October 2026 you can no longer pass that difference on as a surcharge. Our guide to the card surcharge ban covers the change. The ban does not reach bank payments: the RBA's FAQ on it says the change applies to card surcharges on eftpos, Mastercard and Visa, that the RBA does not currently regulate surcharges on non-card payment methods, and that a business can still offer a discount for paying a particular way.
A customer who disputes a direct debit goes to their own bank, which lodges a claim with your provider's bank. Stripe says a customer can dispute a BECS payment through their bank for up to seven years on a "no questions asked" basis, and GoCardless's support guide gives the same seven-year window.
GoCardless's guide to the BECS claims process, last edited in June 2024, describes more of a process than that. The customer's bank must pass the claim on by the next business day. For a claim made within 12 months of the debit, the business's bank must accept or refuse it within 5 business days; for an older claim it has one month. It can refuse by producing evidence of the customer's authority to debit, and if the two banks cannot settle a contested claim within 30 days it may go to the BECS management committee. In practice that defence depends on your provider. Stripe says its BECS disputes have no inquiry phase, that you cannot submit evidence or counter them, and that its dispute fee is not refunded. Its PayTo disputes are final in the same way.
AusPayNet's guidelines for setting up a Direct Debit Request online or by phone tell businesses to keep the request for 7 years after the last debit, and to keep evidence of how they identified the customer and obtained their approval. With a seven-year claim window, that record is the only thing a refusal can rest on.
Every Direct Debit Request comes with a service agreement. AusPayNet's guidelines say it must explain how the customer can cancel, including that they can ask either you or their own bank, and that the customer must get a copy within 7 days. AusPayNet's summary of the direct entry rules says banks must act on a request to stop, cancel or amend a direct debit and make sure no further debits are taken once it is cancelled. If the customer cancels, you lose the right to debit: AusPayNet's guidelines say you are not entitled to debit an account once you no longer have the customer's authority.
GoCardless's guide to Direct Debit Requests, last edited in April 2023, says the service agreement must allow at least 14 business days' notice (its guide to BECS payments says 14 days) before you change its terms or the debit arrangement, tell the customer how to defer, alter or dispute a payment, and set out what happens when a payment fails and whether the customer pays any fees for it. It also says a business that cancels a request without being asked must give 14 business days' notice. Providers can promise more: Stripe's own service agreement commits to at least 30 days' written notice of any change, asks customers to give at least 7 business days' notice before a drawing date to defer, alter or cancel it, and says Stripe may cancel the arrangement after three consecutive dishonoured debits.
Stripe treats notice before each debit as a recommendation rather than a rule. Its documentation says scheme guidelines recommend notifying customers at least 14 calendar days before a payment but that this is not mandatory, and its default email goes out the day before the debit.
A debit can still fail for lack of funds, a closed account or a cancelled request. GoCardless's BECS guide says an unpaid debit must be returned through BECS by close of business on the next working day, and Stripe says it can take up to 2 business days to get the final success or failure notice. Stripe's A$2.50 failure fee is not charged on retries it makes itself; with retries switched on it will try a debit that failed for insufficient funds up to 4 times within 30 days of the first attempt. GoCardless charges no failure fee in Australia. Our guide to UK direct debit fees shows how differently the same problems are priced under Bacs.
PayTo replaces the paper or web-form Direct Debit Request with an agreement the customer approves in their own banking app, setting out the amount, frequency and purpose. Payments confirm in real time instead of after two business days, the customer can see their agreements in one place in their banking, and Stripe notes they can revoke one through their banking app. Stripe's documentation warns that several banks reject PayTo agreements without a specified amount, so a variable bill needs an upper limit set at the start. Australian Payments Plus, which runs the platform, announced in June 2025 that Amazon Australia had added it at checkout.
The pressure to switch has eased. AusPayNet announced June 2030 as a target end-date for BECS in November 2023, then removed it on 16 December 2025, saying most of its members no longer believed the date could be met and that no new date would be set until a roadmap for account-to-account payments is agreed. An A2A Payments Roundtable of AusPayNet, Australian Payments Plus, the RBA and Treasury consulted on a draft vision from 30 April 2026 and published the final version on 8 July 2026. The same day AusPayNet said its outlook for BECS was unchanged, that the industry roadmap would be developed in the second half of 2026, and that its next BECS update would coincide with the roadmap. No closure date for BECS has been set, and AusPayNet says it remains committed to the stability of BECS for as long as it operates.
Collecting in Canada too? Our guide to Canadian PAD fees sets out what pre-authorized debit costs there and how long payers have to dispute it; our guide to SEPA Direct Debit fees covers Europe.


