Payment Processing · Industry

A medical or dental practice takes payments that most shops never see: a copay at check-in, a deductible balance billed weeks later once the insurer has paid, a missed-appointment fee, a $4,000 treatment plan the patient wants to spread out. Each one has its own price, and some of them carry rules that exist only because the payer is a patient.
This guide covers the parts that are specific to healthcare: what HIPAA does and does not require of your card processor, keeping patient cards on file, surcharging, and what patient financing costs the practice. Rates are from each provider's own US pages as read on 18 November 2026.
The HIPAA statute carves card processing out on its own terms. Section 1179 of the Social Security Act (42 U.S.C. 1320d-8) says HIPAA's administrative simplification rules do not apply to an entity acting as a financial institution, or for one, when it authorizes, processes, clears, settles, bills, transfers, reconciles or collects payments for health care or premiums, by card, check or electronic funds transfer. The exemption follows the activity rather than the type of company: it covers an entity processing payments "for a financial institution" as well as the institution itself, which is how non-bank processors that work through a sponsor bank fit within it. PayJunction, for example, describes itself as a registered ISO of PNC Bank.
HHS's business associate guidance applies that directly. It lists, among the situations where no business associate agreement (BAA) is needed, a financial institution that "processes consumer-conducted financial transactions by debit, credit, or other payment card", because it is "not performing a function or activity for, or on behalf of, the covered entity".
The exemption has an edge, and HHS drew it in the 2013 Omnibus Rule preamble: a bank or financial institution "may be a business associate" where it performs functions "above and beyond" payment processing, giving "performing accounts receivable functions on behalf of a health care provider" as the example. The regulation's own definition of a business associate names billing and practice management among the functions that make a vendor one.
That is the line a practice has to watch. Charging a card is exempt. A patient-payment platform that receives balances from your practice-management system, sends statements describing the visit, runs payment plans and chases what is owed is doing billing and receivables work on your behalf, and that is where a BAA belongs. The federal advisory committee on HIPAA, NCVHS, told the HHS Secretary in 2015 that the scope of the exemption needed clearer guidance, listing patient payment portals, patient billing services and payment plans among the services banks had moved into. We found no later HHS guidance changing the exemption.
The processors handle this differently:
Both positions fit the HHS text, because they describe different uses: PayJunction's covers routine payments, Square's covers uses where Square ends up holding health information for you. The practical rule: keep diagnosis and procedure detail out of anything the processor stores, such as invoice line items, payment descriptions and customer notes, unless a BAA covers that product. NCVHS noted that card payments are treated as exempt partly because the cards carry no health information beyond what the payment needs.
Keeping a patient's card to charge a balance after the insurer pays, or a fee for a missed appointment, is a stored-credential transaction under the card network rules. Visa's rules, in the edition dated 24 October 2026, require a merchant that stores a card for future transactions to obtain the cardholder's "express informed consent" to an agreement that includes:
Visa also requires those terms to be shown separately from the general terms when the patient consents, and the merchant to keep the agreement for its duration. A recurring or unscheduled card-on-file charge must not include finance charges or interest, which matters to a practice running its own interest-free payment plans. Visa's rules define a "No-Show Transaction" as one resulting from a failure to cancel or claim a guaranteed reservation, and the data they require for it (a daily room charge or rental rate) is written for hotels and rentals. They do not say how a medical missed-appointment fee should be processed, so ask your processor before charging one. Either way, stating the fee, when it applies and how much it is in the card-on-file consent form covers the cancellation-policy and triggering-event items in the list above.
Medicare allows the fee, with a condition. CMS's Claims Processing Manual says physicians and suppliers may charge Medicare beneficiaries for missed appointments provided they charge non-Medicare patients too, and the same amount. CMS treats the charge as one for "a missed business opportunity" rather than for a service, and says Medicare does not pay it and it should not be billed to Medicare.
Charging a stored card also costs more than tapping one, because it is card-not-present. On Square's free plan a card on file is 3.5% + 15 cents against 2.6% + 15 cents in person, so a $300 balance costs $10.65 charged from the file and $7.95 tapped at the desk. The site's analysis of keyed and card-on-file pricing covers the gap across processors.
Visa allows a US merchant to surcharge credit cards at up to 3%, and never more than the merchant's average processing rate on Visa credit cards, with written notice to the acquirer 30 days before it starts, signs at the entrance and the point of sale, and no surcharge on debit. HSA and FSA cards are debit or prepaid cards, so they cannot be surcharged, and a system that cannot tell them apart from credit cards will get this wrong. Some states restrict surcharges as well. The details are in the site's guide to credit card surcharge rules, and the alternative of a cash discount or dual pricing has its own.
Visa's separate US "service fee" is limited to utilities, schools, courts, fines, taxes and government services; no healthcare category is listed. Visa also permits a "convenience fee", but only as a flat amount for a genuinely alternative channel, such as paying a statement online when the practice normally takes payment at the desk; it must apply to every payment method in that channel and must not be charged solely for accepting a card. So for a practice the surcharge is the only Visa route to passing on card costs as such.
Medicare adds a question we could not settle from official sources. A practice that accepts assignment agrees under 42 CFR 424.55 to accept the Medicare-approved amount as the full charge and to collect from the beneficiary only the difference, such as the deductible and coinsurance. Noridian, a Medicare administrative contractor, describes a violation of assignment as collecting "any amount which, when added to the benefit, exceeds the Medicare allowed amount". We found no CMS or contractor text that addresses card surcharges directly, either way. Ask your Medicare administrative contractor or a healthcare attorney before applying one to a Medicare patient, and check your commercial payer contracts too.
With financing, the lender pays the practice and collects from the patient. The practice pays a fee deducted from the payout, and few lenders publish it.
Two differences matter more than the headline fee. First, whether the fee changes with the plan: Sunbit says its does not, while CareCredit, as cited by the CFPB in 2023, says its rate depends partly on the option the patient chooses. Second, what happens to the patient. CareCredit's promotional plans charge no interest only "if the promo balance is paid in full within the promo period". The CFPB describes these deferred-interest products as charging all the interest accrued since the purchase date if any balance remains, and estimated patients paid about $1 billion of it on healthcare charges from 2018 to 2020. Wisetack's pages describe its plans as simple interest with no deferred interest. Sunbit's dental page says patients never pay deferred interest, but its own footnote reads "Avoid paying interest on a 3-, 12-, or 24-month plan by paying your financed amount within the promotional period", and its rates-and-terms page lists an "Avoid Paying Interest" option, under which interest accrues from the purchase date and is waived only if the financed amount is repaid before the promotion ends, alongside a "True 0% APR" option that accrues none. Ask which one your patients would be offered. The site's analysis of buy now, pay later merchant fees covers the retail side.
Rates below are in-person card rates unless stated, as of 18 November 2026.
Stax and Helcim are on the same basis, so they can be compared. Both add 8 cents to each in-person payment. Stax charges a subscription and no percentage; Helcim charges 0.40% and no subscription. Below about $600,000 a year of card volume, all of it in person and spread evenly across the months (Helcim's tiers are monthly), Helcim's 0.40% margin costs less than Stax's subscription at every tier: at $250,000 a year it is $1,000 against Stax's $1,668, and the two meet at about $597,000 against Stax's $199 minimum. Above that the answer depends on the Stax quote, which is open-ended at $199 or more. Keyed and online payments change the sum, because Helcim's margin rises to 0.50% + 25 cents while Stax's fee is 15 cents. PayJunction's and Gravity's headline rates are a floor and a qualified flat rate, so they cannot be placed on that comparison without a quote.


